Right-click here for hands.
Board 9: East opens 1H, South overcalls 2D, and West has just enough for a 2H raise. North has a good hand for a Responsive Double -- length in the two unbid suits, a tolerance for partner's suit, and about 8-10 hcp at this level. This double applies when the opponents bid and raise a suit and partner makes an intervening overcall or takout double. East has a minimum in hgh cards but good 4-6 shape -- Losing Trick Count suggests an immediate 4H bid. Basically, you expect to lose two spades and three minor suit cards, but hope partner can cover two of those with his raise (6 points might be two Kings or an AQ, etc.) as well as take care of your fourth spade. I'd call that an overbid -- whatever partner has in the minors may not help you, and the fourth spade will often be a problem, but as a competitive bid 4H has a lot going for -- even if it won't make, they may guess wrong and take a phantom sacrifice. 4H ought to be hand like this -- with more in high cards, East should cue-bid or something to show a better defensive hand.
The responsive double tells South about the club fit; should he bid 5C? Not as a sacrifice -- South is looking at 4 possible defensive winners in his own hand, and partner has shown values. Might 5C make? South counts 5 losers and the double suggests three cover cards, but some of North's values rate to be in sapdes, which may not help. How about doubling 4H? This looks reasonable -- a spade lead could be effective if partner has either major suit Ace. No luck -- declarer wins, pulls two rounds of trumps, cashes the remaining spades and ruffs the last in dummy.
Several E/W pairs stopped at 3H. At our table the bidding started 1H-2D-2H-pass; pass. It doesn't pay to let them play 2 of a major (with a fit) so South naturally competes with 3C. West and North passed and East competed with 3H. South and West passed but North made a classic competitive mistake by bidding 4C. This simply chased a reluctant E/W pair into a makeable game they weren't going to bid. Be very cautious about competing over 3 of a major! "Let sleeping dogs lie."
Board 16: North has an Aceless Wonder, but even after deducting a point the hand is well worth a normal 1D opening. East should want to bid something with 6-5 shape, 8 hcp, and a void in diamonds; normally, I would recommend a simple 1H overcall, getting the six-card major into action quickly, but with such poor hearts and good clubs 2NT "Unusual for Two Lower Unbid" is a good alternative, showing both suits at once. South should double to show a good hand -- this is a good general rule, when they bid notrump (naturally or artificially) over partner's bid, double to show strength. West fits both suits, and may be tempted to select the major, but with such a weak hand you don't expect to buy the contract or make anything so 3C looks safer. North would double this with good trumps; today's hand is a balanced minimum, so North passes -- he's already told most of his story with the opening bid. Likewise, East has done enough, so 3C is passed around to South.
Several contracts appear plausible at this point: 3NT if North can stop clubs, 6D if North has a stiff club, 4S if North has a spade fit, or all else failing, 5D. South must bid a game or slam or make an unumistakable forcing bid. The only forcing bid that keeps all contracts in play appears to be 3H -- this must be a cue-bid in the face of East's bid. How should North interpret this? One of Karen Walker's dictums is "game before slam", so North should view 3H as confirming game values and showing a heart stopper. When they've shown two suits, you bid the one you have stopped, inviting partner to bid notrump with a stopper in the other. If South has slam ambitions he'll continue bidding over 3NT.
North cannot stop the clubs and so retreats to 4D; rebidding a five card suit is normal when partner forces you to bid and you have no other obvious choice. South should expect the two losing clubs but has enough to raise to 5D, which is cold.
Vulnerable vs. not, E/W would never sacrifice, but what if the vulnerability were reversed? As it happens 5H goes off three tricks (doubled, of course), so -500 would be a success, but consider the risks when you bid over a five level contract: (1) you may push them into slam and it makes; (2) bad breaks or poorly fitting cards result in -800 or worse; (3) they weren't making 11 tricks. I doubt if many "five over five" bids show a profit.
Sunday, May 27, 2012
Friday, May 11, 2012
Friday, May 11th 2012
Right-click here for hands.
Board 10: East may open 1D, but many would opt for 1NT (15-17.) The alternative is to open 1D and jump rebid 3D; AJxxxx looks a little iffy for that sequence. At notrump, add about half a point for a five card suit and a full point for a six card suit, so this hand rates to be worth 16 at notrump, right in the middle of the agreed range. Over 1NT, West can guess to blast 3NT, 5C, or settle for a part-score in clubs with his xxx x Q10 KQ10xxxx hand. Passing 1NT is unlikely to be optimal.
There are several popular schemes for handling minor suits over 1NT:
(a) 2S = long minor, weak hand; 3C and 3D natural and forcing to game (more or less standard playing Jacoby transfers, barring other agreement.) West's hand looks like 6+ tricks, so it's reasonable to hope either 3NT or 5C will make. Bid 3C; opener can bid a suit toshow a "concentration of values" playable opposite a singleton, bid 3NT to suggest something in both majors, or raise to 4C. Here a plausible auction would be 1NT-3C; 3NT-pass, since whatever opener has in hearts may not be useful at 5C. The idea is to take a shot at 3NT unless it's clearly wrong.
(b) 2S = long minor, weak hand; 3C and 3D natural and invitational (SAYC.) 3C is something of an underbid but is probably better than guessing 5C and is obviously safer than gambling 3NT. 7 hcp and no ace makes 3NT a bit rich for my taste -- the odds of a heart lead are high and odds of 9 running tricks are not so great. 3C involves partner in the decision and game will have better chances if he chooses to bid rather than pass. Another apporach would be to bid 2C, Stayman, followed by 3C, forcing. This replaces the direct jump forcing sequence, at the expense of giving the defense more information and creating a murkier auction. I'd vote for the jump as being simpler, whether or not it is forcing.
(c) 2S = clubs, 2NT = diamonds (weak or strong); 3C and 3D specialized, perhaps showing both minors. Here West responds 2S and East likes his hand -- a fitting club honor and two side Aces. Still, that's only 8 tricks if partner has KQxxxx, and responder will bid game if he has side King to go with that. So East simply accepts the transfer with 3C. What now for West? With no agreements on follow-ups, I don't care much for this sort of transfer; transfer-then-3NT should be a slam try -- if you were always going to bid 3NT, just bid it immediately, don't tell the deefenders about your club suit.
What I think does make sense, however, is that with a long suit, game values and a singleton, responder should transfer and then bid the singleton. You don't need to transfer to a minor and then bid 3H or 3S to show a real suit; start with Stayman if you've got a four-card major. So, 1N-2S; 3C-3H shows 6+ clubs, a singleton heart, and game values. The singleton makes 5 of the minor a plausible alternative to 3NT, and this bidding gives opener enough information to make a reasonable decision most of the time. On today's hand opener guesses 3NT since the clubs might run and 11 tricks are not obvious at 5C. Back to the earlier comment -- when either 3NT or 5C could be right, guess 3NT.
Bottom line bidding tip: if you play minor suit transfers, (1) don't transfer if you are always planning to bid 3NT and (2) use new suit bids after the transfer to show singletons.
Any game bid scored well on today's hand, as East has 9 running tricks and every suit stopped; 5C makes on the diamond finesse (so it was actually rikser than 3NT.) Most pairs played a diamond part-score or defended against hearts, so I assume 1D was the popular opening. West must respond 1NT (!); this does not promise a balanced hand, simply 6-10 hcp and no other bid. (2C would be a gross overbid regardless of system.) North overcalls 2H, not being strong enough to double first. East can expect some help in diamonds -- partner doesn't have either major, so a singleton or void in diamonds is unlikely -- and so can compete to 3D, but North's overcall took away East's jump. I'd suggest 2NT instead, which ought to be this sort of hand -- with a balanced 18, go ahead and bid 3NT in competition, and for heaven's sake don't even think of putting partner in 2NT with a balanced 12-14 count. West will bid 3C given the opportunity, though a bold South may toss in a 3H raise. I think that's pretty rich (vulnerable with a flat 4 count) but could be OK with a partner who makes sound, vulnerable overcalls and is also quite forgiving! If East bid 2NT over 2H, West should try 3NT over 3H, hoping one of the long suits will run. If East bid 3D, West should bid 4C, suggesting this sort of hand -- long clubs, short hearts, and some tolerance for diamonds. Otherwise he would pass and see if partner wants to double.
Board 10: East may open 1D, but many would opt for 1NT (15-17.) The alternative is to open 1D and jump rebid 3D; AJxxxx looks a little iffy for that sequence. At notrump, add about half a point for a five card suit and a full point for a six card suit, so this hand rates to be worth 16 at notrump, right in the middle of the agreed range. Over 1NT, West can guess to blast 3NT, 5C, or settle for a part-score in clubs with his xxx x Q10 KQ10xxxx hand. Passing 1NT is unlikely to be optimal.
There are several popular schemes for handling minor suits over 1NT:
(a) 2S = long minor, weak hand; 3C and 3D natural and forcing to game (more or less standard playing Jacoby transfers, barring other agreement.) West's hand looks like 6+ tricks, so it's reasonable to hope either 3NT or 5C will make. Bid 3C; opener can bid a suit toshow a "concentration of values" playable opposite a singleton, bid 3NT to suggest something in both majors, or raise to 4C. Here a plausible auction would be 1NT-3C; 3NT-pass, since whatever opener has in hearts may not be useful at 5C. The idea is to take a shot at 3NT unless it's clearly wrong.
(b) 2S = long minor, weak hand; 3C and 3D natural and invitational (SAYC.) 3C is something of an underbid but is probably better than guessing 5C and is obviously safer than gambling 3NT. 7 hcp and no ace makes 3NT a bit rich for my taste -- the odds of a heart lead are high and odds of 9 running tricks are not so great. 3C involves partner in the decision and game will have better chances if he chooses to bid rather than pass. Another apporach would be to bid 2C, Stayman, followed by 3C, forcing. This replaces the direct jump forcing sequence, at the expense of giving the defense more information and creating a murkier auction. I'd vote for the jump as being simpler, whether or not it is forcing.
(c) 2S = clubs, 2NT = diamonds (weak or strong); 3C and 3D specialized, perhaps showing both minors. Here West responds 2S and East likes his hand -- a fitting club honor and two side Aces. Still, that's only 8 tricks if partner has KQxxxx, and responder will bid game if he has side King to go with that. So East simply accepts the transfer with 3C. What now for West? With no agreements on follow-ups, I don't care much for this sort of transfer; transfer-then-3NT should be a slam try -- if you were always going to bid 3NT, just bid it immediately, don't tell the deefenders about your club suit.
What I think does make sense, however, is that with a long suit, game values and a singleton, responder should transfer and then bid the singleton. You don't need to transfer to a minor and then bid 3H or 3S to show a real suit; start with Stayman if you've got a four-card major. So, 1N-2S; 3C-3H shows 6+ clubs, a singleton heart, and game values. The singleton makes 5 of the minor a plausible alternative to 3NT, and this bidding gives opener enough information to make a reasonable decision most of the time. On today's hand opener guesses 3NT since the clubs might run and 11 tricks are not obvious at 5C. Back to the earlier comment -- when either 3NT or 5C could be right, guess 3NT.
Bottom line bidding tip: if you play minor suit transfers, (1) don't transfer if you are always planning to bid 3NT and (2) use new suit bids after the transfer to show singletons.
Any game bid scored well on today's hand, as East has 9 running tricks and every suit stopped; 5C makes on the diamond finesse (so it was actually rikser than 3NT.) Most pairs played a diamond part-score or defended against hearts, so I assume 1D was the popular opening. West must respond 1NT (!); this does not promise a balanced hand, simply 6-10 hcp and no other bid. (2C would be a gross overbid regardless of system.) North overcalls 2H, not being strong enough to double first. East can expect some help in diamonds -- partner doesn't have either major, so a singleton or void in diamonds is unlikely -- and so can compete to 3D, but North's overcall took away East's jump. I'd suggest 2NT instead, which ought to be this sort of hand -- with a balanced 18, go ahead and bid 3NT in competition, and for heaven's sake don't even think of putting partner in 2NT with a balanced 12-14 count. West will bid 3C given the opportunity, though a bold South may toss in a 3H raise. I think that's pretty rich (vulnerable with a flat 4 count) but could be OK with a partner who makes sound, vulnerable overcalls and is also quite forgiving! If East bid 2NT over 2H, West should try 3NT over 3H, hoping one of the long suits will run. If East bid 3D, West should bid 4C, suggesting this sort of hand -- long clubs, short hearts, and some tolerance for diamonds. Otherwise he would pass and see if partner wants to double.
Friday, April 20, 2012
Friday, April 20th 2012
Right-click here for hands.
At one table, we defended against 5C, declared 5D, and declared 5C. None of these were the optimal contract! Note that slams and part-scores are often good in a minor, especially when you have a none-card fit or are competing for the part-score. But your attitude toward 5 of a minor should be to try and play either 3NT or 6 of the minor unless both are clearly wrong.
Board 7: South opens 1C. Many prefer 1D with 4-5, especially as here when the diamonds are strong and the clubs weak, but I think such uncertainty about lengths when opener rebids 2C creates as many problems as it purports to solve. North replies 1S, South rebids 2C, and North raises to 3C. With 6 losers, South should not expect partner to cover 4 of them -- unless the enemy bids and raises hearts, marking partner with a shortage there. South's hand is nice but 3C should end the bidding.
If diamonds were never bid, West may fear to underlead his KJ of hearts and may "punt" with a diamond. South wins, cashes two high trumps and dumps his losing hearts on diamonds; a spade toward the King allows South to claim 12 tricks! On an auction like 1D-1S; 2C-3C; pass or 5C, a heart lead is mandatory (if either had hearts stopped they would likely have found notrump) and the defense can claim four tricks quickly.
Board 8: I opened a slightly off-beat 2D, not an uncommon tactic with a good 5 card suit and length in both minors. 2D preempts both majors and sometimes they have trouble finding their fit. Partner inquired with 2NT. We play "features", but when I showed a minimum by rebidding diamonds, partner was under the mistaken impression that all that denied was a side Ace or King. I've always felt a hand like Qx xxx AKxxxxx xx was well above minimum and would not hesitate to bid 3S over a 2NT inquiry. Here, of course, the club Queen would be of enormous value to East. Don't assume "feature" means "Ace or King" without discussing it with partner. Over 3D, East tried to invite game by bidding 4D. Let me make a strong recommendation -- never use 4 of a minor as a game invitation! Game invitations such as 2NT, 3H and 3S are of limited value; using 4 of a minor in the same way is a dead loser. Four of a minor should always be a slam try except in those rare cases where one player bids 3NT as a mere suggestion (the previous bidding making it clear he has doubts about notrump) and partner pulls it. East should pass 3D; with less infomration, gambling 5D might be reasonable.
If West passes initially, East opens 1C and South jumps to 2S. This leaves West with no convenient bid. North rasies to 3S or 4S -- the balanced shape and "poison Queen" (in East's clubs) argue for caution while the known 11 card fit favors the more agressive bid. I would raise a 1S overcall only to 2, but I think 4S is likely best over 2S. West may as well double at matchpoints, with two quick tricks opposite a partner who opened the bidding. Two high diamonds and a heart switch net five tricks (+300) for the defense.
Board 9: East opens 1NT (15-17); West has lively slam interest if a minor suit fit can be found, but the combined values (30-32 hcp) are a bit thin for 6NT. Ideal here would be 2S as Minor Suit Stayman (game-forcing and asking for a four card minor.) More common is to play 2S as a weak hand with a long minor, or some sort of transfer scheme, such as 2S = clubs and 2NT = diamonds. A simple approach would be transfer to clubs and then rebid 3NT -- this is a clear slam try; with mere game values West should raise to 3NT and not mention the clubs. With five card support and 3 key cards East should then drive to slam, likely using 4NT to confirm one Ace or Key card.
Not playing transfers, 3C should be natural, forcing to game, and suggests an unbalanced hand and/or slam interest -- again, no reason to bid clubs on the way to 3NT with mere game values. Opener assumes partner may have a singleton and should bid a suit where he has a "concentratin of values" sufficient to play notrump if that's partner's singleton. Here, East's AJ tight of spades does not look strong enough and East's next best bet is to bid 3NT, suggesting something in both majors. What about diamonds? Well, partner has to have points somewhere and they may lead a major anyway. Responder will generally pull this with a singleton since opener failed to show any particular concentration.
After 1NT-3C; 3NT, responder may pass or try for slam. I'd say responder has 5 1/2 losers and at 3 points a trick it's a fair bet opener can cover 5 of them. Try visualizing: Kx Ax KQxx QJ1098 opposite Axx Kxx Axxx Kx would make any of 6C, 6D or 6NT a heavy favorite; Axx Kxx Axx Kxxx looks good for 6C on a dummy reversal. Partner won't necessarily have such perfect cards but you should have good chances if he has extra values. Lacking a sure fit 4NT, quantitative, looks right; partner can show club support via 5C or 6C if he likes his hand. While I generally play "notrump-over-notrump" as quantitative, there's a major exception -- when responder jump shifts and 4NT at his next opportunity, it should be asking about key-cards for his suit. With only one key card, West cannot handle a 5D or 5S reply so 4NT is too risky if it would be taken as any form of Blackwood. West must proceed with a natural 4C or 4D or a 4D or 4H cue-bid. All should clearly be taken as slam tries and East should be happy to cooperate.
One other approach: Stayman. 1NT-2C; 2 any - 3C or 3D are game-forcing, and many partnerships have no other way to show a minor suit on the way to game or to investigate slam. Despite the Stayman inquiry, such rebids do not promise a major suit in standard methods (unlike notrump rebids, which must be alerted if no major suit is imlied.) I like to play the immediate jumps (3C and 3D) as one-suited hands and use Stayman with two suits, even if both are minors.
So: 1NT-2C; 2D-3C. The 2D reply assures West there must be a fit, and partner does not have clubs he can bid 3D. On today's hand East has a big club fit but must remember the target is still 3NT if possible. 3NT seems more of a gamble after this auction (partner may be 3415 or such) so East must either raise clubs or try 3S. I think 3S is best -- if responder now bids 3NT, the implication is that he was short in spades and opener is justified in pulling to 4C with his excellent support. Instead, responder today is encouraged by the assured fit and spade bid -- it looks like he can dump a heart loser on spades. The problem with 4NT remains, so over 3S responder bids 4D and opener can easily proceed with 4NT, trusting responder's bidding to indicate real slam interest.
At one table, we defended against 5C, declared 5D, and declared 5C. None of these were the optimal contract! Note that slams and part-scores are often good in a minor, especially when you have a none-card fit or are competing for the part-score. But your attitude toward 5 of a minor should be to try and play either 3NT or 6 of the minor unless both are clearly wrong.
Board 7: South opens 1C. Many prefer 1D with 4-5, especially as here when the diamonds are strong and the clubs weak, but I think such uncertainty about lengths when opener rebids 2C creates as many problems as it purports to solve. North replies 1S, South rebids 2C, and North raises to 3C. With 6 losers, South should not expect partner to cover 4 of them -- unless the enemy bids and raises hearts, marking partner with a shortage there. South's hand is nice but 3C should end the bidding.
If diamonds were never bid, West may fear to underlead his KJ of hearts and may "punt" with a diamond. South wins, cashes two high trumps and dumps his losing hearts on diamonds; a spade toward the King allows South to claim 12 tricks! On an auction like 1D-1S; 2C-3C; pass or 5C, a heart lead is mandatory (if either had hearts stopped they would likely have found notrump) and the defense can claim four tricks quickly.
Board 8: I opened a slightly off-beat 2D, not an uncommon tactic with a good 5 card suit and length in both minors. 2D preempts both majors and sometimes they have trouble finding their fit. Partner inquired with 2NT. We play "features", but when I showed a minimum by rebidding diamonds, partner was under the mistaken impression that all that denied was a side Ace or King. I've always felt a hand like Qx xxx AKxxxxx xx was well above minimum and would not hesitate to bid 3S over a 2NT inquiry. Here, of course, the club Queen would be of enormous value to East. Don't assume "feature" means "Ace or King" without discussing it with partner. Over 3D, East tried to invite game by bidding 4D. Let me make a strong recommendation -- never use 4 of a minor as a game invitation! Game invitations such as 2NT, 3H and 3S are of limited value; using 4 of a minor in the same way is a dead loser. Four of a minor should always be a slam try except in those rare cases where one player bids 3NT as a mere suggestion (the previous bidding making it clear he has doubts about notrump) and partner pulls it. East should pass 3D; with less infomration, gambling 5D might be reasonable.
If West passes initially, East opens 1C and South jumps to 2S. This leaves West with no convenient bid. North rasies to 3S or 4S -- the balanced shape and "poison Queen" (in East's clubs) argue for caution while the known 11 card fit favors the more agressive bid. I would raise a 1S overcall only to 2, but I think 4S is likely best over 2S. West may as well double at matchpoints, with two quick tricks opposite a partner who opened the bidding. Two high diamonds and a heart switch net five tricks (+300) for the defense.
Board 9: East opens 1NT (15-17); West has lively slam interest if a minor suit fit can be found, but the combined values (30-32 hcp) are a bit thin for 6NT. Ideal here would be 2S as Minor Suit Stayman (game-forcing and asking for a four card minor.) More common is to play 2S as a weak hand with a long minor, or some sort of transfer scheme, such as 2S = clubs and 2NT = diamonds. A simple approach would be transfer to clubs and then rebid 3NT -- this is a clear slam try; with mere game values West should raise to 3NT and not mention the clubs. With five card support and 3 key cards East should then drive to slam, likely using 4NT to confirm one Ace or Key card.
Not playing transfers, 3C should be natural, forcing to game, and suggests an unbalanced hand and/or slam interest -- again, no reason to bid clubs on the way to 3NT with mere game values. Opener assumes partner may have a singleton and should bid a suit where he has a "concentratin of values" sufficient to play notrump if that's partner's singleton. Here, East's AJ tight of spades does not look strong enough and East's next best bet is to bid 3NT, suggesting something in both majors. What about diamonds? Well, partner has to have points somewhere and they may lead a major anyway. Responder will generally pull this with a singleton since opener failed to show any particular concentration.
After 1NT-3C; 3NT, responder may pass or try for slam. I'd say responder has 5 1/2 losers and at 3 points a trick it's a fair bet opener can cover 5 of them. Try visualizing: Kx Ax KQxx QJ1098 opposite Axx Kxx Axxx Kx would make any of 6C, 6D or 6NT a heavy favorite; Axx Kxx Axx Kxxx looks good for 6C on a dummy reversal. Partner won't necessarily have such perfect cards but you should have good chances if he has extra values. Lacking a sure fit 4NT, quantitative, looks right; partner can show club support via 5C or 6C if he likes his hand. While I generally play "notrump-over-notrump" as quantitative, there's a major exception -- when responder jump shifts and 4NT at his next opportunity, it should be asking about key-cards for his suit. With only one key card, West cannot handle a 5D or 5S reply so 4NT is too risky if it would be taken as any form of Blackwood. West must proceed with a natural 4C or 4D or a 4D or 4H cue-bid. All should clearly be taken as slam tries and East should be happy to cooperate.
One other approach: Stayman. 1NT-2C; 2 any - 3C or 3D are game-forcing, and many partnerships have no other way to show a minor suit on the way to game or to investigate slam. Despite the Stayman inquiry, such rebids do not promise a major suit in standard methods (unlike notrump rebids, which must be alerted if no major suit is imlied.) I like to play the immediate jumps (3C and 3D) as one-suited hands and use Stayman with two suits, even if both are minors.
So: 1NT-2C; 2D-3C. The 2D reply assures West there must be a fit, and partner does not have clubs he can bid 3D. On today's hand East has a big club fit but must remember the target is still 3NT if possible. 3NT seems more of a gamble after this auction (partner may be 3415 or such) so East must either raise clubs or try 3S. I think 3S is best -- if responder now bids 3NT, the implication is that he was short in spades and opener is justified in pulling to 4C with his excellent support. Instead, responder today is encouraged by the assured fit and spade bid -- it looks like he can dump a heart loser on spades. The problem with 4NT remains, so over 3S responder bids 4D and opener can easily proceed with 4NT, trusting responder's bidding to indicate real slam interest.
Friday, April 13, 2012
Friday, April 13th, 2012
Right-click here for hands. OK, I haven't blogged in a few months, so maybe no one will read this. If any one does, maybe post a comment and let me know what you'd like to see?
Board 2: South opens 1H or 2NT. On values, 2NT looks right, but the bid crowds the auction and I'm reluctant to bid that with such a wealth of slam controls and a good major suit. Over 1H, in standard methods North has just enough for 2D, planning to sign off next round with 3D. For 2/1 Game Force bidders, North must start with 1NT (forcing.)
After 1H-2D, South has trouble showing his shape and strength. Any of 2S, 3C or 3H creates a game-force; 3C looks best as it is always riskier to misrepresent major suit length. A jump to 3NT would suggest 17-19 balanced but that is all too likely to end the bidding. Like most game bids, it's descriptive, not a "shut-out", the problem here is that the hand is too strong. (You must add a point for all four Aces, and the strong suit is also a plus value.) Over 3C North rebids diamonds as planned; now what does South do? Seems like South must bid 3NT after all and North has no reason to bid further. Nine pairs stopped at 3NT.
If North starts with a forcing 1NT, South leaps to 3NT. After a minor suit opening this would suggest a long suit, but as it would be natural to jump in a long major this sequence suggests 19-21 and 5332 or close to it. North counts 10 hcp, subtracts one for no Ace, but can add for the long suit. I'd view North's hand as 5 diamond and one club trick; at 3 points per trick partenr could easily provide the six more needed for slam. With a lack of entries North should aim for 6D rather than 6NT. 4D ought clearly be this sort of hand -- it would be silly to take a game-bid out to a part-score, so 4D should be a natural slam try. South should figure he has everything North could want; if 4NT would be Blackwood, go ahead and bid it so you can follow up with 5NT to show partner all the Aces. If 4NT might be taken as a sign-off over 4D, just leap to 6D. Experts might try 5NT but would that be "Grand Slam Force" or "Pick a Slam" ? Although 6NT and 7D can both make, 6D scores a near top.
If South opens 2NT (the hand is worth about 20.5 at notrump) North's analysis is similar to the 1H-1NT-3NT sequence, with perhaps a bit more thought of reaching grand slam. But does your partnership have an agreed way to show a long minor with slam interest over 2NT? 3S ought to be some sort of minor-suited hand, so perhaps 2NT-3S; 3NT-4D; 4NT (RKCB)- 5D (one key card); 5H (Q ask)-5S or 6D (whichever says "got it"); pass. Even 12 tricks may require some work and it may be useful to set up the hearts with ruffs so 6D still looks best.
An opening spade establishes a trick quickly for the defense and removes a vital entry from dummy. Declarer should counter by hoping hearts are no worse than 4-2: Ace of spades, AK of hearts, ruff a heart high, high diamond, diamond to the Ace, ruff a heart high, pull trumps, low club to the Ace, pitch the losing spade and concede a club. 6NT appears to need a non-spade lead or a squeeze.
Board 4: North opens 1C and East has no convenient bid -- if you double with this sort of hand, what do you do if partner replies in diamonds? If you double and then bid again over diamonds, then you have no way to show a strong hand. However, many players automatically double with opening count, but I've never seen a good explanation of follow-up bidding for that style.
Assuming East passes, what about South? My expectation with such a weak hand is that if I bid, partner is likely to jump. Even if 1C "could be short", it isn't forcing and you certaily can stand clubs. I've always felt pass now and consider bidding later (having limited you values) to be the best approach with weak hands.
After (1C)-pass-(pass), West balances with 1S. His hand could be much weaker so East should proceed with caution. Over North's pass the usual aapproach is for East to mentally transfer a King to partner -- he "borrowed" that for his balancing bid -- and then bid as if responding to an opening bid with three fewer points. So East has a solid game-invitational raise. The normal approach would be to cue-bid 2C -- but you'd better be sure partner won't think that's natural! A simple jump to 3S is probably safest. Back to West -- if he adds that "borrowed" King to his hand he should accept the invitation. So 4S looks like the normal contract but 8 of 13 pairs failed to reach game.
North has no attractive lead. Opposite a weak partner punting with a diamond looks right; the free finesse is one West could take himself. West loses a heart, a club and perhaps another trick (such as a second club if he has to break the suit himself.)
At our table South manufactured a 1D response, West overcalled 1S, North innocently bid a normal-looking 1NT, and East doubled for blood. This marks East with opening bid values but no suit to overcall and a hand unsuitable for a takeout double. Most doubles of notrump should be assumed to be penalty, not takeout, except the double of a 1NT response when your partner passed: (1C)-(1D); (1NT)-dbl would be for takeout, but West's spade overcall changes the equation.
I think South should pull 1NT doubled to 2C, but playing "short club" South was afraid to do so. That's even more reason to pass 1C initially IMO.
Board 2: South opens 1H or 2NT. On values, 2NT looks right, but the bid crowds the auction and I'm reluctant to bid that with such a wealth of slam controls and a good major suit. Over 1H, in standard methods North has just enough for 2D, planning to sign off next round with 3D. For 2/1 Game Force bidders, North must start with 1NT (forcing.)
After 1H-2D, South has trouble showing his shape and strength. Any of 2S, 3C or 3H creates a game-force; 3C looks best as it is always riskier to misrepresent major suit length. A jump to 3NT would suggest 17-19 balanced but that is all too likely to end the bidding. Like most game bids, it's descriptive, not a "shut-out", the problem here is that the hand is too strong. (You must add a point for all four Aces, and the strong suit is also a plus value.) Over 3C North rebids diamonds as planned; now what does South do? Seems like South must bid 3NT after all and North has no reason to bid further. Nine pairs stopped at 3NT.
If North starts with a forcing 1NT, South leaps to 3NT. After a minor suit opening this would suggest a long suit, but as it would be natural to jump in a long major this sequence suggests 19-21 and 5332 or close to it. North counts 10 hcp, subtracts one for no Ace, but can add for the long suit. I'd view North's hand as 5 diamond and one club trick; at 3 points per trick partenr could easily provide the six more needed for slam. With a lack of entries North should aim for 6D rather than 6NT. 4D ought clearly be this sort of hand -- it would be silly to take a game-bid out to a part-score, so 4D should be a natural slam try. South should figure he has everything North could want; if 4NT would be Blackwood, go ahead and bid it so you can follow up with 5NT to show partner all the Aces. If 4NT might be taken as a sign-off over 4D, just leap to 6D. Experts might try 5NT but would that be "Grand Slam Force" or "Pick a Slam" ? Although 6NT and 7D can both make, 6D scores a near top.
If South opens 2NT (the hand is worth about 20.5 at notrump) North's analysis is similar to the 1H-1NT-3NT sequence, with perhaps a bit more thought of reaching grand slam. But does your partnership have an agreed way to show a long minor with slam interest over 2NT? 3S ought to be some sort of minor-suited hand, so perhaps 2NT-3S; 3NT-4D; 4NT (RKCB)- 5D (one key card); 5H (Q ask)-5S or 6D (whichever says "got it"); pass. Even 12 tricks may require some work and it may be useful to set up the hearts with ruffs so 6D still looks best.
An opening spade establishes a trick quickly for the defense and removes a vital entry from dummy. Declarer should counter by hoping hearts are no worse than 4-2: Ace of spades, AK of hearts, ruff a heart high, high diamond, diamond to the Ace, ruff a heart high, pull trumps, low club to the Ace, pitch the losing spade and concede a club. 6NT appears to need a non-spade lead or a squeeze.
Board 4: North opens 1C and East has no convenient bid -- if you double with this sort of hand, what do you do if partner replies in diamonds? If you double and then bid again over diamonds, then you have no way to show a strong hand. However, many players automatically double with opening count, but I've never seen a good explanation of follow-up bidding for that style.
Assuming East passes, what about South? My expectation with such a weak hand is that if I bid, partner is likely to jump. Even if 1C "could be short", it isn't forcing and you certaily can stand clubs. I've always felt pass now and consider bidding later (having limited you values) to be the best approach with weak hands.
After (1C)-pass-(pass), West balances with 1S. His hand could be much weaker so East should proceed with caution. Over North's pass the usual aapproach is for East to mentally transfer a King to partner -- he "borrowed" that for his balancing bid -- and then bid as if responding to an opening bid with three fewer points. So East has a solid game-invitational raise. The normal approach would be to cue-bid 2C -- but you'd better be sure partner won't think that's natural! A simple jump to 3S is probably safest. Back to West -- if he adds that "borrowed" King to his hand he should accept the invitation. So 4S looks like the normal contract but 8 of 13 pairs failed to reach game.
North has no attractive lead. Opposite a weak partner punting with a diamond looks right; the free finesse is one West could take himself. West loses a heart, a club and perhaps another trick (such as a second club if he has to break the suit himself.)
At our table South manufactured a 1D response, West overcalled 1S, North innocently bid a normal-looking 1NT, and East doubled for blood. This marks East with opening bid values but no suit to overcall and a hand unsuitable for a takeout double. Most doubles of notrump should be assumed to be penalty, not takeout, except the double of a 1NT response when your partner passed: (1C)-(1D); (1NT)-dbl would be for takeout, but West's spade overcall changes the equation.
I think South should pull 1NT doubled to 2C, but playing "short club" South was afraid to do so. That's even more reason to pass 1C initially IMO.
Friday, February 24, 2012
Friday, February 24th 2012
Right-click here for hands.
Board 2: An intersting competitive hand. After two passes, West opens 1S and North overcalls 2D. North might jump, but his good hand should have him thinking "maybe we have a game" not " I need to jam the bidding." East is too weak for 2H or 2NT; what about a negative double? Styles vary; I prefer to have a realtively balanced hand for the double, including two in partner's suit -- partner must bid something, and there's no assurance he will have a second suit, so I think it's prudent to have a tolerance for his announced suit. I'd pass but would not be overly critical of a double. After South also passes, West should re-open the bidding -- it won't pay to sell out to 2 of a suit you are void in. Never minf only 11 hcp, West's shape demands a bid. The choices include double, 2H, and 2S. I like 2S: partner's failure to double reduces the chance of a heart fit (surely he has some values on this auction), chances are good he has two spades, and the bid suggests limited values. I'd hate to double and have partner guess to pass for penalties. North has good defense against spades but the seven diamonds should be rebid; after that North can consider defending. 3D is passed around to West, who should think "6-4, bid one more", especially with the void; I'd try 3H. North passes and East comes alive with a raise to 4H, which ought to end the bidding. If North or South compete to 5D East should double and collect 500.
With his strong spades, North leads out the Ace of trumps, trying to limit West's ability to ruff out the spades. Of course dummy's 5th trump cancels that plan; what next? West has shown 6-4 shape; a singelton or void in diamonds seems likely. Trying to cash the Ace of diamonds will likely set up a discard for a club, and leading clubs may finesse partner. I'd continue with a low spade -- declarer can ruff out the spades, but North can't prevent that. Declarer finesses in trumps, pulls the last trump, cashes the King of spades, ruffs a spade (noting South shows out) and leads a club honor from dummy -- North has shown long diamonds in the bidding and four spades during the play, so it looks right to play South for the clubs. South covers the Queen or Ten and eventually collects the second and last trick for the defense. If declarer plays the clubs "normally", without clues from the bidding, Ace of clubs and a low club to the Queen will give the defense an extra trick.
Several pairs sacrificed at 5D, which proves too expensive. South's relatively flat hand is not suitable for heroics, and as mentioned North has too much defense in West's spades to bid more than 3D.
Board 9: After two passes, South should open 3C. A good six-card suit is fine for that bid when not vulnerable -- better than passing, and you don't have the alternative of a weak two. West doubles with his powerhouse, planning to bid spades later. East beats him to it; should West simply raiase to 4 or contemplate slam? Counting five losers, it seems unlikely partner can cover four of them on a hand that didn't jump, so I'd settle for 4S after some thought. 4S making six was the normal result, one pair bidding slam -- perhaps East did jump, or South failed to open 3C. If West is allowed to open 1S, some "Law of Total Tricks" fans would leap to 4S with East's hand (10 trumps = 10 trick level); I don't think that's sound without the customary singleton but on today's hand West is inspired by the big fit and may continue to slam by way of Blackwood or RKCB. Five clubs doubled -- trying to sacrifice at the five level with only 8 trumps -- got hammered for 1100.
Board 15: Perhaps most would open 3C with West's hand, not vulnerable vs. vulnerable, but my philosophy is that the enemy will usually brush aside such feeble preempts; I prefer around 5-9 hcp and a fair suit for a three bid in first or second seat.
If West does open 3C, East should reason that he can cover all of partner's side-suit losers, and with his King there should be no more than one trump losers, so a Blackwood or RKCB auction should land the partnership in six clubs, an easy contract. If West passes, East opens 2C; West bids 2D negative (0-7), waiting (0+), or semi-positive (4+, where 2H would show a bust); or 2H "no Ace or King", or "steps" (4-6.) Assuming 2D semi-positive, East bids 2H and West bids 3C, natural. It's hard to come up with something other than 3NT by East. West is likely to pass rather than risk taking out what may be the only makeable game.
After a negative or waiting 2D, 3C by West would be a "second round negative" showing a potentially trickless hand; who knows what partner will think of a club leap? This is a trap hand for most partnerships using such methods. I would say four clubs must be natural if 3C is artificial, but I wouldn't assume partner would take it that way without discussion; he might read it as a splinter raise of hearts. Perhaps a negative 3C followed by four or five clubs would be best.
Over a "steps" 2H, East must bid 3H, or a highly distorted 2NT. That's the downside of "steps" : the 2H and 2S responses often jams the bidding. However, I think precise high card information is something most players can understand and use effectively. On today's hand West must bid clubs at the four level, which leaves East with a nearly insoluble rebid problem; I'd assume the clubs were fairly long and raise to five.
Board 17: After North and East pass, South opens 2C. Only 18 hcp, but plenty of tricks and slam controls. One guideline is "more quick tricks than losers"; South has 4.5 QT's and only 3 losers; another is "game in hand" with at least four quick tricks including two Aces. A typical auction might be 2C-2D; 2S-2NT; 3S-3NT; 4H. South emphasizes the spades before introducing the hearts. With 9 hcp opposite a 2C opener, North should proceed toward slam once the fit is discovered, with 4NT revealing three Aces or four key cards.
Against 6H, West leds the King of clubs, won perforce by South's stiff ace. Making slam requires setting up the spades with no loser. If both majors break 3-2, a single ruff will suffice; can declarer plan for one bad break or the other? A 4-1 trump break can be handled only if the Jack or Ten drops singleton and declarer retains a finessing position over the other honor. That suggests cashing the Ace of hearts and, if either the honor drops, continuing with the Queen or low to the King as appropiate. But you still have to ruff a spade, or resort to the finesse, so it will be hard to cope with four tumps in West's hand.
What about spades 4-1? You'll need two ruffs, which means you can't pull three rounds of trumps, which means there's a risk of dummy being over-ruffed. On today's hand a succesful line would be to cash a high sapde and ruff one before pulling any trumps. The King of trumps in dummy protects against West ruffing with the ten. return to hand with a club ruff, ruff another spade, and then pull trumps. I'm not sure what the best theoretical line is.
Board 23: West opens 1C; if North can bid 3C naturally, this is a good hand for it -- good offense, little defense. East bids 3S, West raise to 4S, East asks for key cards and West shows two with 5H. That leaves only the fifth diamond as a possible loser; 7S should be cold but 7NT looks to be a heavy favorite since AKQJ is likely to pull all the remaining diamonds, or partner may have a side King, or the Ten of diamonds, etc. You want very good odds to bid any grand slam but 7NT looks to be a good bet. Declarer claims 17 tricks on any lead -- OK, they'll only let you score 13.
Playing simple Blackwood, West shows one Ace and then two Kings. East cannot be sure tha includes the King of spades, but West should realize that and raise six spades to seven. That's why you NEVER bid 5NT after 4NT without all the Aces -- 5NT doesn't merely ask for Kings, it confirms all the Aces (or key cards) and invites grand slam.
Board 2: An intersting competitive hand. After two passes, West opens 1S and North overcalls 2D. North might jump, but his good hand should have him thinking "maybe we have a game" not " I need to jam the bidding." East is too weak for 2H or 2NT; what about a negative double? Styles vary; I prefer to have a realtively balanced hand for the double, including two in partner's suit -- partner must bid something, and there's no assurance he will have a second suit, so I think it's prudent to have a tolerance for his announced suit. I'd pass but would not be overly critical of a double. After South also passes, West should re-open the bidding -- it won't pay to sell out to 2 of a suit you are void in. Never minf only 11 hcp, West's shape demands a bid. The choices include double, 2H, and 2S. I like 2S: partner's failure to double reduces the chance of a heart fit (surely he has some values on this auction), chances are good he has two spades, and the bid suggests limited values. I'd hate to double and have partner guess to pass for penalties. North has good defense against spades but the seven diamonds should be rebid; after that North can consider defending. 3D is passed around to West, who should think "6-4, bid one more", especially with the void; I'd try 3H. North passes and East comes alive with a raise to 4H, which ought to end the bidding. If North or South compete to 5D East should double and collect 500.
With his strong spades, North leads out the Ace of trumps, trying to limit West's ability to ruff out the spades. Of course dummy's 5th trump cancels that plan; what next? West has shown 6-4 shape; a singelton or void in diamonds seems likely. Trying to cash the Ace of diamonds will likely set up a discard for a club, and leading clubs may finesse partner. I'd continue with a low spade -- declarer can ruff out the spades, but North can't prevent that. Declarer finesses in trumps, pulls the last trump, cashes the King of spades, ruffs a spade (noting South shows out) and leads a club honor from dummy -- North has shown long diamonds in the bidding and four spades during the play, so it looks right to play South for the clubs. South covers the Queen or Ten and eventually collects the second and last trick for the defense. If declarer plays the clubs "normally", without clues from the bidding, Ace of clubs and a low club to the Queen will give the defense an extra trick.
Several pairs sacrificed at 5D, which proves too expensive. South's relatively flat hand is not suitable for heroics, and as mentioned North has too much defense in West's spades to bid more than 3D.
Board 9: After two passes, South should open 3C. A good six-card suit is fine for that bid when not vulnerable -- better than passing, and you don't have the alternative of a weak two. West doubles with his powerhouse, planning to bid spades later. East beats him to it; should West simply raiase to 4 or contemplate slam? Counting five losers, it seems unlikely partner can cover four of them on a hand that didn't jump, so I'd settle for 4S after some thought. 4S making six was the normal result, one pair bidding slam -- perhaps East did jump, or South failed to open 3C. If West is allowed to open 1S, some "Law of Total Tricks" fans would leap to 4S with East's hand (10 trumps = 10 trick level); I don't think that's sound without the customary singleton but on today's hand West is inspired by the big fit and may continue to slam by way of Blackwood or RKCB. Five clubs doubled -- trying to sacrifice at the five level with only 8 trumps -- got hammered for 1100.
Board 15: Perhaps most would open 3C with West's hand, not vulnerable vs. vulnerable, but my philosophy is that the enemy will usually brush aside such feeble preempts; I prefer around 5-9 hcp and a fair suit for a three bid in first or second seat.
If West does open 3C, East should reason that he can cover all of partner's side-suit losers, and with his King there should be no more than one trump losers, so a Blackwood or RKCB auction should land the partnership in six clubs, an easy contract. If West passes, East opens 2C; West bids 2D negative (0-7), waiting (0+), or semi-positive (4+, where 2H would show a bust); or 2H "no Ace or King", or "steps" (4-6.) Assuming 2D semi-positive, East bids 2H and West bids 3C, natural. It's hard to come up with something other than 3NT by East. West is likely to pass rather than risk taking out what may be the only makeable game.
After a negative or waiting 2D, 3C by West would be a "second round negative" showing a potentially trickless hand; who knows what partner will think of a club leap? This is a trap hand for most partnerships using such methods. I would say four clubs must be natural if 3C is artificial, but I wouldn't assume partner would take it that way without discussion; he might read it as a splinter raise of hearts. Perhaps a negative 3C followed by four or five clubs would be best.
Over a "steps" 2H, East must bid 3H, or a highly distorted 2NT. That's the downside of "steps" : the 2H and 2S responses often jams the bidding. However, I think precise high card information is something most players can understand and use effectively. On today's hand West must bid clubs at the four level, which leaves East with a nearly insoluble rebid problem; I'd assume the clubs were fairly long and raise to five.
Board 17: After North and East pass, South opens 2C. Only 18 hcp, but plenty of tricks and slam controls. One guideline is "more quick tricks than losers"; South has 4.5 QT's and only 3 losers; another is "game in hand" with at least four quick tricks including two Aces. A typical auction might be 2C-2D; 2S-2NT; 3S-3NT; 4H. South emphasizes the spades before introducing the hearts. With 9 hcp opposite a 2C opener, North should proceed toward slam once the fit is discovered, with 4NT revealing three Aces or four key cards.
Against 6H, West leds the King of clubs, won perforce by South's stiff ace. Making slam requires setting up the spades with no loser. If both majors break 3-2, a single ruff will suffice; can declarer plan for one bad break or the other? A 4-1 trump break can be handled only if the Jack or Ten drops singleton and declarer retains a finessing position over the other honor. That suggests cashing the Ace of hearts and, if either the honor drops, continuing with the Queen or low to the King as appropiate. But you still have to ruff a spade, or resort to the finesse, so it will be hard to cope with four tumps in West's hand.
What about spades 4-1? You'll need two ruffs, which means you can't pull three rounds of trumps, which means there's a risk of dummy being over-ruffed. On today's hand a succesful line would be to cash a high sapde and ruff one before pulling any trumps. The King of trumps in dummy protects against West ruffing with the ten. return to hand with a club ruff, ruff another spade, and then pull trumps. I'm not sure what the best theoretical line is.
Board 23: West opens 1C; if North can bid 3C naturally, this is a good hand for it -- good offense, little defense. East bids 3S, West raise to 4S, East asks for key cards and West shows two with 5H. That leaves only the fifth diamond as a possible loser; 7S should be cold but 7NT looks to be a heavy favorite since AKQJ is likely to pull all the remaining diamonds, or partner may have a side King, or the Ten of diamonds, etc. You want very good odds to bid any grand slam but 7NT looks to be a good bet. Declarer claims 17 tricks on any lead -- OK, they'll only let you score 13.
Playing simple Blackwood, West shows one Ace and then two Kings. East cannot be sure tha includes the King of spades, but West should realize that and raise six spades to seven. That's why you NEVER bid 5NT after 4NT without all the Aces -- 5NT doesn't merely ask for Kings, it confirms all the Aces (or key cards) and invites grand slam.
Friday, February 17, 2012
Friday, February 17th 2012
Right-click here for hands.
Board 3: West opens 1D; East has an excellent 15 hcp with 5-5 in the black suits. Simple Losing Trick Count would rate East's hand at 4 losers, enough for slam opposite an less than an opening bid. But that's fairly optimistic; first, you must locate a fit, and even then it's more reasonable to look sceptically at the fourth card in both suits unless partner shows four-card support. The opening bid in your singleton isn't encouraging; partner rates to have wasted values and there's a fairly small chacne of getting a useful discard. Still, it's a powerhouse; how to proceed? A jump shift would show slam interest immediately, but won't leave enough room below 3NT to show the 5-5 shape. A simple 1S is probably best for the moment, planning to jump in clubs later.
West rebids 1NT. "Keep It Simple" bidders must jump to 3C to force to game; this won't promise 5-5, and doesn't really do justice to the playing strength. West rebids 3NT (most of his points are in the red suits) and East must decide to pass or continue with no known fit. I think pass is prudent.
If your partnership plays New Minor Forcing, the jump to 3C can be more specific. A typical game-invitational or better hand with five spades would bid 2C (artificial) to check back for 3 card support, so the jump in a new suit can be defined as 5-5 or better (game-forcing.) West would be aware of the 5-3 club fit, but would still bid 3NT with so much in the red suits. Slam makes, but wouldn't if clubs split badly or the heart finesse were off. If West were 4-4 in the minors rather than 5-3, slam would be excellent.
Board 9: East opens 1H and South may overcall white vs. red despite only 6 hcp. Regardless, West bids 2C, but 2/1 Game Force bidders should be aware that such a bid is not forcing to game over interference. East raises to 3C -- this should promise extra values and be game-forcing. With a minimum hand East rebids hearts before supporting clubs. West adds his 16 hcp to opener's 14+, defintely slam territory after the raise; but West is noticebly lacking in key cards. It's too much to count on partner for 3 key cards and a 5D or 5H resposne to 4NT makes it impossible to stop at 5C. 5NT may be playable but is apt to be risky. Instead, West bids 3D over 3C. Initially this sounds like a probe for 3NT ("game before slam" is one of Karen Walker's key bidding principles.) East rebids the hearts, looking for two-card support. West could raise hearts but that would give up on slam, so West makes another try with 3S. Notrump probe or slam try? Sounds like a slam try since West could bid notrump himself with stoppers in both diamonds and spades.
East, with three key cards (at clubs) plus a void should drive to slam after this bidding -- it sounds like West has the tricks but did not want to risk 4NT himself (as was, in fact, the case.) East bids 4NT followed by 6C over partner's one-Ace reply. Should West correct to 6H? I'd say no -- some pairs will miss slam altogether, and 6C protects the King of spades and stands to gain on almost any lead. Also, hearts might fail on a bad trump split, while the nine-card club fit may allow setting hearts up with a ruff. As it happens, South has the spade Ace and hearts break 3-2, but 6C scores about average. At a team game 6C would be clear-cut.
At our table North doubled 3D for a lead, and at least one N/S pair reached 5D (-800.) Looks like South has a reasonable Michael's cue-bid, 2H over 1H showing 5-5 with spades and a minor. West doubles to show a strong, relatively balanced hand (11+ hcp, much like a redouble of a takeout double.) North bids 2NT to ask for South's minor; East guesses (correctly) South has diamonds and bids 3C in front of him. South bids 3D; what now for West? It's not hard to picture partner with AQ of hearts, AK of clubs and short diamonds for his unforced 3C bid, so I think West can drive to slam.
Board 17: North opens 1D, South responds 1H and East can consider bidding any number of spades from one to four. Twelve highs would be too much for an opening preempt, but with both opponents bidding and partner passing description isn't the chief priority. Still, West has about six losers and East might cover three of them. Pure preemption argues for 3S, but the chance they can make 4H or you can make 4S argues for 1S (to give partner a chance to double them later) or 4S (make 'em guess!) The suit, while possessing good intermediates, lacks top tricks so I decided on 1S. North can rebid 2C (or employ a Support Double, opener's double of an overcall showing exactly 3 card support for responder's major. This is a popular expert gadget but is frought with danger for most partnerships.) South looks askance at his Queen of spades, but his shape is good and with 11 hcp South jumps to 3D, inviting game. North bids 3H, accepting the game try and showing delayed (three-card) support. South raises to game.
It's usually a poor strategy to let the opponents exchange information and then sacrifice; they'll generally guess correctly whether to double you or bid on. Here, however, West can reasonably hope to take 7 tricks with his own hand and with the enemy announcing a double-fit, it's reasonable to hope for one trick from partner for a paying sacrifice -- if they can make 4H. On defense, only a couple of tricks seem likely, and no reason to expect partner to provide two. I did in fact bid 4S at this point, doubled -300 and a good score. N/S can make 5H or 6D, but I don't see a clear case for either to risk the five level.
Board 3: West opens 1D; East has an excellent 15 hcp with 5-5 in the black suits. Simple Losing Trick Count would rate East's hand at 4 losers, enough for slam opposite an less than an opening bid. But that's fairly optimistic; first, you must locate a fit, and even then it's more reasonable to look sceptically at the fourth card in both suits unless partner shows four-card support. The opening bid in your singleton isn't encouraging; partner rates to have wasted values and there's a fairly small chacne of getting a useful discard. Still, it's a powerhouse; how to proceed? A jump shift would show slam interest immediately, but won't leave enough room below 3NT to show the 5-5 shape. A simple 1S is probably best for the moment, planning to jump in clubs later.
West rebids 1NT. "Keep It Simple" bidders must jump to 3C to force to game; this won't promise 5-5, and doesn't really do justice to the playing strength. West rebids 3NT (most of his points are in the red suits) and East must decide to pass or continue with no known fit. I think pass is prudent.
If your partnership plays New Minor Forcing, the jump to 3C can be more specific. A typical game-invitational or better hand with five spades would bid 2C (artificial) to check back for 3 card support, so the jump in a new suit can be defined as 5-5 or better (game-forcing.) West would be aware of the 5-3 club fit, but would still bid 3NT with so much in the red suits. Slam makes, but wouldn't if clubs split badly or the heart finesse were off. If West were 4-4 in the minors rather than 5-3, slam would be excellent.
Board 9: East opens 1H and South may overcall white vs. red despite only 6 hcp. Regardless, West bids 2C, but 2/1 Game Force bidders should be aware that such a bid is not forcing to game over interference. East raises to 3C -- this should promise extra values and be game-forcing. With a minimum hand East rebids hearts before supporting clubs. West adds his 16 hcp to opener's 14+, defintely slam territory after the raise; but West is noticebly lacking in key cards. It's too much to count on partner for 3 key cards and a 5D or 5H resposne to 4NT makes it impossible to stop at 5C. 5NT may be playable but is apt to be risky. Instead, West bids 3D over 3C. Initially this sounds like a probe for 3NT ("game before slam" is one of Karen Walker's key bidding principles.) East rebids the hearts, looking for two-card support. West could raise hearts but that would give up on slam, so West makes another try with 3S. Notrump probe or slam try? Sounds like a slam try since West could bid notrump himself with stoppers in both diamonds and spades.
East, with three key cards (at clubs) plus a void should drive to slam after this bidding -- it sounds like West has the tricks but did not want to risk 4NT himself (as was, in fact, the case.) East bids 4NT followed by 6C over partner's one-Ace reply. Should West correct to 6H? I'd say no -- some pairs will miss slam altogether, and 6C protects the King of spades and stands to gain on almost any lead. Also, hearts might fail on a bad trump split, while the nine-card club fit may allow setting hearts up with a ruff. As it happens, South has the spade Ace and hearts break 3-2, but 6C scores about average. At a team game 6C would be clear-cut.
At our table North doubled 3D for a lead, and at least one N/S pair reached 5D (-800.) Looks like South has a reasonable Michael's cue-bid, 2H over 1H showing 5-5 with spades and a minor. West doubles to show a strong, relatively balanced hand (11+ hcp, much like a redouble of a takeout double.) North bids 2NT to ask for South's minor; East guesses (correctly) South has diamonds and bids 3C in front of him. South bids 3D; what now for West? It's not hard to picture partner with AQ of hearts, AK of clubs and short diamonds for his unforced 3C bid, so I think West can drive to slam.
Board 17: North opens 1D, South responds 1H and East can consider bidding any number of spades from one to four. Twelve highs would be too much for an opening preempt, but with both opponents bidding and partner passing description isn't the chief priority. Still, West has about six losers and East might cover three of them. Pure preemption argues for 3S, but the chance they can make 4H or you can make 4S argues for 1S (to give partner a chance to double them later) or 4S (make 'em guess!) The suit, while possessing good intermediates, lacks top tricks so I decided on 1S. North can rebid 2C (or employ a Support Double, opener's double of an overcall showing exactly 3 card support for responder's major. This is a popular expert gadget but is frought with danger for most partnerships.) South looks askance at his Queen of spades, but his shape is good and with 11 hcp South jumps to 3D, inviting game. North bids 3H, accepting the game try and showing delayed (three-card) support. South raises to game.
It's usually a poor strategy to let the opponents exchange information and then sacrifice; they'll generally guess correctly whether to double you or bid on. Here, however, West can reasonably hope to take 7 tricks with his own hand and with the enemy announcing a double-fit, it's reasonable to hope for one trick from partner for a paying sacrifice -- if they can make 4H. On defense, only a couple of tricks seem likely, and no reason to expect partner to provide two. I did in fact bid 4S at this point, doubled -300 and a good score. N/S can make 5H or 6D, but I don't see a clear case for either to risk the five level.
Sunday, February 12, 2012
Sunday, February 12th 2012
Right-click here for hands.
Board 12: West deals and opens 2C. East has a straightforward positive response in diamonds (3D). Any other bid, such as 2D waiting, risks missing slam when you cannot portray such a good hand later. For those who use step responses, East bids 2S to show 7-9 hcp; there should be time to bid the diamonds later. Over 3D, West bids 3NT, suggesting a balanced 22 or more; the bid is unlimited and forcing -- a positive response should be treated as forcing to at least 4 hearts. That gives both players some time to describe their hands. 4C would suggest that West was weak in one of the majors, perhaps with a singleton. East raises 3NT to 4NT with his minimum (no point in mentioning the anemic hearts, you wouldn't want to play slam in such a poor suit); a sound principle is that "notrump over notrump" is never Ace-asking, except when responder makes a strong jump shift and follows immediately with 4NT -- that bid always asks about Aces, or key cards for responder's suit, regardless of opener's rebid.
It looks like an easy raise to 6NT -- opener has 24 hcp, not 22, and either clubs or diamonds should provide the necessary tricks. But partner's bidding suggests no outside entry -- with AKxxx in diamonds and the King of clubs on the side, responder would bid 6NT himself. The clubs may need some work to set up. 6D would be a thoughtful bid.
At 6NT, West can count four major suit winners, at least three diamonds, and at least two clubs after losing a trick to the King. So declarer must find three more tricks. If diamonds split 3-3 the suit can be run and the club finesse attempted, but more club tricks will be needed. (Declarer doesn't know the Jack of spades will provide a trick; it would be foolish to cash the AK of spades before playing on clubs.) Win the opening lead (probably the ten of spades), cash the Queen of diamonds, overtake the Jack, cash the last high diamond, finesse the Queen of clubs, and finally play the Ace and pray. The King falls and declarer gives up to the ten of clubs before claiming.
Our opponents reached 6C after a bidding mistake -- East replied 2D waiting, and tried to follow with a natural 3D. But the agreement was "cheapest minor = 2nd negative" and West was afraid to bid 3NT with no help in diamonds. Over 4C, East leaped to 6C but admitted 6NT was probably a better shot. Declarer tried to play clubs out of her hand and lost tricks to both the King and ten. I really hate "2D waiting" as a response scheme; I'd rather play any of 2D negative (0-7), 2H bust (so 2D shows some values), or step responses (high cards please, not controls.) The "roaming 2nd negative" is a real pain when opener rebids 3C or 3D rather than the expected 2H, 2S or 2NT.
Board 14: East opens a weak 2S. South doubles as his 19 hcp is too strong for a simple 2NT (15-18, same as 1NT over 1 of a suit.) West should raise to 3S! No high cards but three trumps and a singleton; West does not expect 3S to have any play at all but N/S surely have a game or slam that is worth more than setting 3S doubled.
North has a five-loser hand; the double should provide 4 cover cards and the spade bids suggest little of partner's strength is opposite the void, so a slam looks likely. Opposite any normal takeout double 6H would be right; but the suit could use help and 6D or 7D might be better. The trick is to avoid making a bid partner can pass short of slam. 4S would certainly be forcing but it's hard to come up with a way to show both suits. I think 6H directly is the practical bid, or possibly 5S (showing the void) followed by 6H to allow partner a chance to bid the grand. Six making seven was worth a solid 5.5 out of 8 matchpoints.
Board 18: East may open 2S in a very undisciplined style, but most would pass owing to the poor suit and/or side four-card major. Afer South passes West opens 2D, weak, or if 2D would mean something else, a very agressive 3D -- North is marked with a good hand and it pays to jam the bidding in third seat. North's monster 1-5-1-6 hand is hard to bid; experts play "Leaping Michaels", where a leap to 4C or 4D over a weak two shows a strong two-suited hand with the bid suit and an unbid major. Lacking that treatment the usual procedure is for North to double and then bid one of his suits to show a strong hand. I avoid doing that with a singleton in an unibd major (sapdes in this case), but North is so strong that he can afford to show his club suit at the five or even six level if necessary.
South jumps to 3S, showing about 9-11 in value and four or more spades. For those playing lebensohl, South can clarify his spade length by bidding 2NT (a relay to 3C) followed by 3S, showing only a four card suit. Lacking that agreement, South jumps to 3S and North bids 4C. That should be forcing where 4H risks partner's passing. South ahs already shown a good hand, but the club support and two Aces are unexpected assets and it makes sense to cue-bid 4D. North bids 4H (another cue-bid, no way to show the hearts on this auction), South cue-bids 4S, and North bids 4NT to ask for Aces or key-cards. Over Sout's 5H reply North bids 5NT to confirm all the Aces and a good trup suit, but South is done and bids 6C to deny any side Kings or other assets that would justify bidding seven. Declarer pulls two rounds of trumps and then tries to ruff a heart before pulling the last trump. When West drops the Queen, South can pull the last trump and concede one heart to the Jack, or try leading the ten of hearts -- if East covers, ruff and it's OK if West over-ruffs; if East plays low, pitch from dummy. If West wins the Jack the rest of the hearts are good and the last trump can be pulled; on today's layout West ruffs but there is still a trump in dummy to ruff out the Jack.
Board 12: West deals and opens 2C. East has a straightforward positive response in diamonds (3D). Any other bid, such as 2D waiting, risks missing slam when you cannot portray such a good hand later. For those who use step responses, East bids 2S to show 7-9 hcp; there should be time to bid the diamonds later. Over 3D, West bids 3NT, suggesting a balanced 22 or more; the bid is unlimited and forcing -- a positive response should be treated as forcing to at least 4 hearts. That gives both players some time to describe their hands. 4C would suggest that West was weak in one of the majors, perhaps with a singleton. East raises 3NT to 4NT with his minimum (no point in mentioning the anemic hearts, you wouldn't want to play slam in such a poor suit); a sound principle is that "notrump over notrump" is never Ace-asking, except when responder makes a strong jump shift and follows immediately with 4NT -- that bid always asks about Aces, or key cards for responder's suit, regardless of opener's rebid.
It looks like an easy raise to 6NT -- opener has 24 hcp, not 22, and either clubs or diamonds should provide the necessary tricks. But partner's bidding suggests no outside entry -- with AKxxx in diamonds and the King of clubs on the side, responder would bid 6NT himself. The clubs may need some work to set up. 6D would be a thoughtful bid.
At 6NT, West can count four major suit winners, at least three diamonds, and at least two clubs after losing a trick to the King. So declarer must find three more tricks. If diamonds split 3-3 the suit can be run and the club finesse attempted, but more club tricks will be needed. (Declarer doesn't know the Jack of spades will provide a trick; it would be foolish to cash the AK of spades before playing on clubs.) Win the opening lead (probably the ten of spades), cash the Queen of diamonds, overtake the Jack, cash the last high diamond, finesse the Queen of clubs, and finally play the Ace and pray. The King falls and declarer gives up to the ten of clubs before claiming.
Our opponents reached 6C after a bidding mistake -- East replied 2D waiting, and tried to follow with a natural 3D. But the agreement was "cheapest minor = 2nd negative" and West was afraid to bid 3NT with no help in diamonds. Over 4C, East leaped to 6C but admitted 6NT was probably a better shot. Declarer tried to play clubs out of her hand and lost tricks to both the King and ten. I really hate "2D waiting" as a response scheme; I'd rather play any of 2D negative (0-7), 2H bust (so 2D shows some values), or step responses (high cards please, not controls.) The "roaming 2nd negative" is a real pain when opener rebids 3C or 3D rather than the expected 2H, 2S or 2NT.
Board 14: East opens a weak 2S. South doubles as his 19 hcp is too strong for a simple 2NT (15-18, same as 1NT over 1 of a suit.) West should raise to 3S! No high cards but three trumps and a singleton; West does not expect 3S to have any play at all but N/S surely have a game or slam that is worth more than setting 3S doubled.
North has a five-loser hand; the double should provide 4 cover cards and the spade bids suggest little of partner's strength is opposite the void, so a slam looks likely. Opposite any normal takeout double 6H would be right; but the suit could use help and 6D or 7D might be better. The trick is to avoid making a bid partner can pass short of slam. 4S would certainly be forcing but it's hard to come up with a way to show both suits. I think 6H directly is the practical bid, or possibly 5S (showing the void) followed by 6H to allow partner a chance to bid the grand. Six making seven was worth a solid 5.5 out of 8 matchpoints.
Board 18: East may open 2S in a very undisciplined style, but most would pass owing to the poor suit and/or side four-card major. Afer South passes West opens 2D, weak, or if 2D would mean something else, a very agressive 3D -- North is marked with a good hand and it pays to jam the bidding in third seat. North's monster 1-5-1-6 hand is hard to bid; experts play "Leaping Michaels", where a leap to 4C or 4D over a weak two shows a strong two-suited hand with the bid suit and an unbid major. Lacking that treatment the usual procedure is for North to double and then bid one of his suits to show a strong hand. I avoid doing that with a singleton in an unibd major (sapdes in this case), but North is so strong that he can afford to show his club suit at the five or even six level if necessary.
South jumps to 3S, showing about 9-11 in value and four or more spades. For those playing lebensohl, South can clarify his spade length by bidding 2NT (a relay to 3C) followed by 3S, showing only a four card suit. Lacking that agreement, South jumps to 3S and North bids 4C. That should be forcing where 4H risks partner's passing. South ahs already shown a good hand, but the club support and two Aces are unexpected assets and it makes sense to cue-bid 4D. North bids 4H (another cue-bid, no way to show the hearts on this auction), South cue-bids 4S, and North bids 4NT to ask for Aces or key-cards. Over Sout's 5H reply North bids 5NT to confirm all the Aces and a good trup suit, but South is done and bids 6C to deny any side Kings or other assets that would justify bidding seven. Declarer pulls two rounds of trumps and then tries to ruff a heart before pulling the last trump. When West drops the Queen, South can pull the last trump and concede one heart to the Jack, or try leading the ten of hearts -- if East covers, ruff and it's OK if West over-ruffs; if East plays low, pitch from dummy. If West wins the Jack the rest of the hearts are good and the last trump can be pulled; on today's layout West ruffs but there is still a trump in dummy to ruff out the Jack.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)